diff --git a/custom/knowledge/architecture/mode-b-reconciliation-must-be-per-repository-not-global-sha-gated.md b/custom/knowledge/architecture/mode-b-reconciliation-must-be-per-repository-not-global-sha-gated.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..eef3017 --- /dev/null +++ b/custom/knowledge/architecture/mode-b-reconciliation-must-be-per-repository-not-global-sha-gated.md @@ -0,0 +1,69 @@ +--- +bc-version: [all] +domain: architecture +keywords: [mode-b, curabis-standard, auto-update, agents, per-repository, sha-gate, race-condition] +technologies: [al] +countries: [w1] +application-area: [all] +--- + +## Description + +`.github/.agents/` is a per-repository artifact — every CURABIS project has its +own, independent copy. But the BCQuality version marker that gates whether +Mode B runs (`~/.claude/.bcquality-version`) is a single file shared across +every local repository on the developer's machine. This mismatch creates a +race condition: whichever project's session happens to be the first to notice +a BCQuality change runs Mode B and advances the shared marker — every other +local project then sees "SHA unchanged" and silently skips its own Mode B +reconciliation, even though its `.github/.agents/` was never checked against +the new template state. + +This was observed directly: two Mode B runs in one project advanced the shared +marker to a given SHA. Any other CURABIS project opened afterward would see +that same SHA as already current and skip Mode B entirely — permanently +missing any template file (e.g. a newly added agent) that arrived in that +BCQuality change, unless the developer manually re-triggers the update in +that specific project. + +## Rule + +Mode B reconciliation (diffing the template file list against `.github/.agents/`) +must be tracked with a marker local to each repository — not solely by the +shared global BCQuality version file. A suggested mechanism: maintain a local, +git-ignored per-repo marker (e.g. `.github/.agents/.bcquality-version`) recording +the BCQuality SHA against which *this* repository's Mode B reconciliation last +ran. The global marker may still gate whether the shared knowledge-file cache +needs re-fetching from the network — but it must never be the sole gate for +whether Mode B executes for a given repository. + +## What NOT to do + +- Do not treat "global SHA unchanged" as proof that this repository's agents are current +- Do not skip Mode B for a repository just because another project's session already advanced the shared marker +- Do not rely on developer memory to manually re-run "Opdater CURABIS Standard" in every sibling project after a BCQuality change +- Do not conflate the network-cache-freshness concern (global, fine to share) with the per-repo-reconciliation concern (must not be shared) + +## Signal to watch for + +At session start, compare: + +``` +Local per-repo marker: .github/.agents/.bcquality-version (if present) +``` + +against the current BCQuality main SHA. If they differ (or the local marker is +missing), run Mode B reconciliation for this repository regardless of what the +global `~/.claude/.bcquality-version` file says. + +## Message to developer + +When a per-repo reconciliation gap is found, output exactly this before continuing: + +``` +⚠️ Dette repository er ikke reconciled mod seneste BCQuality-SHA, selvom den +globale versions-fil allerede er opdateret (formentlig af et andet projekt). +Kører Mode B-reconciliation for dette repo nu. +``` + +Do not silently skip Mode B just because the global marker looks current.