Merge 49b14834c4 into b503249751

microsoft/skills/review/al-data-modeling-review.md

@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ application-area: [all]
 
 Reviews AL source changes against the `data-modeling` knowledge domain in BCQuality and emits a findings report. This is a leaf action skill: it invokes no sub-skills. It is one of the skills composed by `al-code-review`.
 
-An orchestrator invokes this skill with a `pr-diff`, `file-path`, or `folder-path`. Data-modeling findings are narrow by design — they apply when the review scope contains setup or master tables, their card pages, primary keys, number-series assignment, block enforcement, audit fields, document print/email/Post-and-Send actions, `Navigate` page subscribers, Report Selection registration or dispatch, price-calculation/price-source extensibility, code that reads or writes sales/purchase/service line price and amount fields, `TransferFields`-based posting-cascade field mirroring, barcode/report-layout font-provider usage, dimension wiring, journal-based posting-routine structure, or Item Ledger Entry document-number lookups after a combined sales post. The skill returns `not-applicable` when none of those apply.
+An orchestrator invokes this skill with a `pr-diff`, `file-path`, or `folder-path`. Data-modeling findings are narrow by design — they apply when the review scope contains setup or master tables, their card pages, primary keys, number-series assignment, block enforcement, audit fields, document print/email/Post-and-Send actions, `Navigate` page subscribers, Report Selection registration or dispatch, price-calculation/price-source extensibility, code that reads or writes sales/purchase/service line price and amount fields, `TransferFields`-based posting-cascade field mirroring, `TableRelation` field-length design, barcode/report-layout font-provider usage, dimension wiring, journal-based posting-routine structure, or Item Ledger Entry document-number lookups after a combined sales post. The skill returns `not-applicable` when none of those apply.
 
 ## Source
 
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ Narrow the relevant files to the subset that applies to the changes under review
 
 - The changed AL object names and types — especially `* Setup` singleton tables and Card pages, custom master tables, tableextensions that add master-data fields, document or journal lines that reference a master, document pages/codeunits exposing print/email/Post-and-Send actions, codeunits subscribing to `Navigate`, enumextensions to `"Report Selection Usage"`/`"Price Calculation Handler"`/`"Price Source Type"`, and report objects that render barcodes.
 - The changed fields, keys, triggers, and procedures, weighted toward `Primary Key`, `No.`, `No. Series`, `Blocked`, `Last Date Modified`, `OnInsert`, `OnModify`, `OnRename`, reference-field `OnValidate`, posting validation, and posting-cascade `TransferFields` calls.
-- Tokens extracted from the diff that relate to data modeling (`setup`, `master`, `Primary Key`, `Code[10]`, `Code[20]`, `AutoIncrement`, `SystemId`, `No.`, `No. Series`, `NoSeriesManagement`, `Codeunit "No. Series"`, `GetNextNo`, `IsManual`, `TestManual`, `Blocked`, `TestField`, `Last Date Modified`, `Today`, `WorkDate`, `InsertAllowed`, `DeleteAllowed`, `PageType = Card`, `OnOpenPage`, `GetRecordOnce`, `OnInsert`, `OnModify`, `OnRename`, `InitRecord`, `Round`, `Precision`, `Direction`, `TableRelation`, `tableextension`, `enumextension`, `Media`, `MediaSet`, `Item`, `Count`, `TransferFields`, `Navigate`, `OnAfterFindRecords`, `OnBeforeShowRecords`, `Report Selections`, `Report Selection Usage`, `InsertRecord`, `Document Sending Profile`, `PrintForCust`, `PrintWithDialogForCust`, `PrintWithDialogForVend`, `SendEmailToCust`, `SendEmailToVendor`, `Report.RunModal`, `Report.Run`, `Price Calculation Handler`, `Price Calculation`, `OnFindSupportedSetup`, `Price Calculation Setup`, `Price Source Type`, `PriceSourceList`, `OnAfterAddSources`, `UpdateUnitPrice`, `PlanPriceCalcByField`, `UpdateUnitPriceByField`, `Prices Including VAT`, `Unit Price`, `Direct Unit Cost`, `Line Amount`, `Prepmt. Line Amount`, `Amount Including VAT`, `CalculateOutstandingAmountExclTax`, `Barcode Font Provider`, `Barcode Font Provider 2D`, `EncodeFont`, `ValidateInput`).
+- Tokens extracted from the diff that relate to data modeling (`setup`, `master`, `Primary Key`, `Code[10]`, `Code[20]`, `AutoIncrement`, `SystemId`, `No.`, `No. Series`, `NoSeriesManagement`, `Codeunit "No. Series"`, `GetNextNo`, `IsManual`, `TestManual`, `Blocked`, `TestField`, `Last Date Modified`, `Today`, `WorkDate`, `InsertAllowed`, `DeleteAllowed`, `PageType = Card`, `OnOpenPage`, `GetRecordOnce`, `OnInsert`, `OnModify`, `OnRename`, `InitRecord`, `Round`, `Precision`, `Direction`, `TableRelation`, `ValidateTableRelation`, `TestTableRelation`, `Text[`, `tableextension`, `enumextension`, `Media`, `MediaSet`, `Item`, `Count`, `TransferFields`, `Navigate`, `OnAfterFindRecords`, `OnBeforeShowRecords`, `Report Selections`, `Report Selection Usage`, `InsertRecord`, `Document Sending Profile`, `PrintForCust`, `PrintWithDialogForCust`, `PrintWithDialogForVend`, `SendEmailToCust`, `SendEmailToVendor`, `Report.RunModal`, `Report.Run`, `Price Calculation Handler`, `Price Calculation`, `OnFindSupportedSetup`, `Price Calculation Setup`, `Price Source Type`, `PriceSourceList`, `OnAfterAddSources`, `UpdateUnitPrice`, `PlanPriceCalcByField`, `UpdateUnitPriceByField`, `Prices Including VAT`, `Unit Price`, `Direct Unit Cost`, `Line Amount`, `Prepmt. Line Amount`, `Amount Including VAT`, `CalculateOutstandingAmountExclTax`, `Barcode Font Provider`, `Barcode Font Provider 2D`, `EncodeFont`, `ValidateInput`).
 
 A file enters the candidate worklist when its `keywords` intersect the extracted tokens or its topic (derived from the index entry's `path`, `title`, and `description`) matches a changed object type. Read an article's full file — its `## Best Practice` / `## Anti Pattern` bodies — only after it makes the worklist; candidate selection uses the index alone. When the diff contains no data-modeling changes by any of the above signals, return `outcome: "not-applicable"` without evaluating files.
 
@@ -55,6 +55,7 @@ The following targeted checks cover every current `data-modeling` article. Treat
 - A master gains or changes `Blocked`, or a document line, journal line, reference-field `OnValidate`, or posting routine uses that master without `TestField(Blocked, false)` at the point of use; also cue when the check is placed only in the master's own triggers — `check-blocked-in-referencing-code-not-in-master`.
 - A master table adds or changes `Last Date Modified`, `OnModify`, or `OnRename`, but the non-editable field is not assigned `Today()` in both triggers — `set-last-date-modified-in-onmodify-and-onrename`.
 - A `tableextension` appends a conditional `TableRelation` as if it overrides an earlier unconditional relation, or relation branches are otherwise designed without accounting for additive top-down evaluation — `table-relation-extensions-are-additive-and-top-down`.
+- A field declares a `TableRelation` (or a `tableextension` `modify` adds a relation branch) and the field's declared `Code`/`Text` length is shorter than the related field, or, when any relation on the field is unconditional, differs from it — `tablerelation-field-length-must-match-related-field`. Read the related field's declared length from its table definition rather than assuming one. A field shorter than the related field is a finding in all cases, including when it sets `ValidateTableRelation = false` or `TestTableRelation = false`. Do not flag a field for being longer than its related field when its relations are all conditional, or when it sets `ValidateTableRelation = false` or `TestTableRelation = false` (filter/totaling fields).
 - A `Media` or `MediaSet` field is assigned directly between different table types or different field IDs instead of registering each shared item with `MediaSet.Insert` — `share-mediaset-items-with-insert-not-field-assignment`.
 - A custom document header assigns defaults outside an `InitRecord` boundary, calls `InitRecord` before assigning its number, or places UI-independent defaults only in a page trigger — `initialize-document-defaults-in-initrecord`.
 - Directed `Round` calls use `'<'` as mathematical floor or `'>'` as mathematical ceiling, especially where negative amounts are possible — `round-direction-symbols-use-magnitude`.
@@ -101,7 +102,7 @@ Outcome selection:
 
 - `completed` — the skill evaluated every worklist item.
 - `no-knowledge` — no applicable data-modeling knowledge survived filtering.
-- `not-applicable` — the diff touches no setup/master table, page, key, numbering, block-check, or audit-field surface, and no document print/email/Post-and-Send action, `Navigate` subscriber, Report Selection registration/dispatch, price-calculation/price-source extensibility point, sales/purchase/service line price or amount read/write, posting-cascade `TransferFields` mirroring, barcode/report-font-provider usage, dimension wiring, posting-routine structure, or Item-Ledger-Entry-document-number surface.
+- `not-applicable` — the diff touches no setup/master table, page, key, numbering, block-check, or audit-field surface, and no document print/email/Post-and-Send action, `Navigate` subscriber, Report Selection registration/dispatch, price-calculation/price-source extensibility point, sales/purchase/service line price or amount read/write, posting-cascade `TransferFields` mirroring, `TableRelation` field length, barcode/report-font-provider usage, dimension wiring, posting-routine structure, or Item-Ledger-Entry-document-number surface.
 - `partial` — a budget was hit before the worklist was exhausted.
 - `failed` — an unrecoverable error occurred.
 

microsoft/skills/review/al-testing-review.md

@@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ application-area: [all]
 
 Reviews AL source changes against the `testing` knowledge domain in BCQuality and emits a findings report. This is a leaf action skill: it invokes no sub-skills. It is one of the skills composed by `al-code-review`.
 
-An orchestrator invokes this skill with a `pr-diff`, `file-path`, or `folder-path`. Testing findings are narrow by design — they apply when the review scope contains test codeunits, test runners, test methods, handlers, assertions, or fixture construction. The skill returns `not-applicable` when none of those apply.
+An orchestrator invokes this skill with a `pr-diff`, `file-path`, or `folder-path`. Testing findings are narrow by design — they apply when the review scope contains test codeunits, test runners, test methods, handlers, assertions, fixture construction, or test-library helpers such as `RecordRef`-based uniqueness checks. The skill returns `not-applicable` when none of those apply.
 
 ## Source
 
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ Narrow the relevant files to the subset that applies to the changes under review
 
 - The changed AL object names and types — especially codeunits with `Subtype = Test`, test runner codeunits with `TestIsolation`, test libraries, and codeunits that define UI handlers.
 - The changed methods and attributes, weighted toward `[Test]`, `[TransactionModel(...)]`, `[TestPermissions(...)]`, `[HandlerFunctions(...)]`, handler attributes, `asserterror`, `ExpectedError`, `ExpectedErrorCode`, fixture initialization, and test-library calls.
-- Tokens extracted from the diff that relate to testing (`Subtype = Test`, `Subtype = TestRunner`, `TestIsolation`, `TestPermissions`, `Restrictive`, `NonRestrictive`, `Disabled`, `Permissions Mock`, `Library - Lower Permissions`, `TransactionModel`, `AutoRollback`, `AutoCommit`, `Commit`, `asserterror`, `ExpectedError`, `ExpectedErrorCode`, `HandlerFunctions`, `ConfirmHandler`, `MessageHandler`, `StrMenuHandler`, `ModalPageHandler`, `SendNotificationHandler`, `RecallNotificationHandler`, `Enqueue`, `Dequeue`, `AssertEmpty`, `Initialize`, `IsInitialized`, `OnTestInitialize`, `LibrarySetupStorage`, `Library Assert`, `LibraryVariableStorage`, `LibrarySales`, `LibraryPurchase`, `LibraryERM`, `LibraryInventory`, `LibraryRandom`, `Library - Utility`, `LibraryUtility`, `GenerateGUID`, `GenerateRandomCode`, `TestPage`, `.Visible(`, `.Enabled(`, `.Editable(`, `OpenNew`, `OpenView`, `OpenEdit`, `Init`, `Insert`).
+- Tokens extracted from the diff that relate to testing (`Subtype = Test`, `Subtype = TestRunner`, `TestIsolation`, `TestPermissions`, `Restrictive`, `NonRestrictive`, `Disabled`, `Permissions Mock`, `Library - Lower Permissions`, `TransactionModel`, `AutoRollback`, `AutoCommit`, `Commit`, `asserterror`, `ExpectedError`, `ExpectedErrorCode`, `HandlerFunctions`, `ConfirmHandler`, `MessageHandler`, `StrMenuHandler`, `ModalPageHandler`, `SendNotificationHandler`, `RecallNotificationHandler`, `Enqueue`, `Dequeue`, `AssertEmpty`, `Initialize`, `IsInitialized`, `OnTestInitialize`, `LibrarySetupStorage`, `Library Assert`, `LibraryVariableStorage`, `LibrarySales`, `LibraryPurchase`, `LibraryERM`, `LibraryInventory`, `LibraryRandom`, `Library - Utility`, `LibraryUtility`, `GenerateGUID`, `GenerateRandomCode`, `RecordRef`, `RecRef.Open`, `IsEmpty`, `TestPage`, `.Visible(`, `.Enabled(`, `.Editable(`, `OpenNew`, `OpenView`, `OpenEdit`, `Init`, `Insert`).
 
 A file enters the candidate worklist when its `keywords` intersect the extracted tokens or its topic (derived from the index entry's `path`, `title`, and `description`) matches a changed object type. Read an article's full file — its `## Best Practice` / `## Anti Pattern` bodies — only after it makes the worklist; candidate selection uses the index alone. When the diff contains no testing-related changes by any of the above signals, return `outcome: "not-applicable"` without evaluating files.
 
@@ -60,6 +60,7 @@ The following targeted checks cover every current `testing` article. Treat each
 - A shared/lazy `Initialize()`-style fixture helper creates fixture data without a following `Commit()`, in a test method whose body later forces its own rollback (for example `asserterror Error(...)` used for end-of-test cleanup) — `commit-shared-test-fixture-inside-lazy-initialize`. The presence of `Commit()` after the fixture is the compliant shape, not the signal to look for; the missing-`Commit()` shape combined with a later deliberate rollback is the anti-pattern. Require runner/repository context for the `TestIsolation` value: a standalone test file cannot prove which runner executes it, and under `Function`-level isolation this whole pattern is moot regardless of `Commit()` — do not raise the finding when the executing runner's `TestIsolation` is known to be `Function`.
 - Changed code subscribes to `OnAfterRemoveTableRelation`, calls `RemoveTableRelation`, or references `Codeunit "Table Relation Test"`/134926 — `table-relation-test-exclude-known-invalid-relations-via-event`.
 - Test fixture code assigns a hardcoded literal to a primary-key field or a field the test relies on as a unique lookup identifier, hand-builds a "unique" value for such a field (string concatenation, a counter, `Format(CurrentDateTime)`), or truncates `LibraryUtility.GenerateGUID()`'s result with `CopyStr` for such a field shorter than 10 characters — `use-generateguid-for-unique-test-fixture-values`. Calling `GenerateGUID()` untruncated into a full-length field, `GenerateRandomCodeWithLength` for a shorter field needing real verified uniqueness, or `GenerateRandomCode20` specifically for a `Code[20]` field, is the compliant shape, not the signal to flag. `GenerateRandomCode20` is not a substitute for `GenerateRandomCodeWithLength` on a shorter field — it truncates `GenerateGUID()`'s sequential value down to the field's length by keeping the *leftmost* characters, which change the slowest, so retries against a short field can churn through the same truncated prefix far longer than `GenerateRandomCodeWithLength`'s equivalent. A hardcoded or deterministic value in an ordinary descriptive field is not this anti-pattern — that field carries no uniqueness constraint. Do not claim `GenerateRandomCode` (without `WithLength`/`20`) or `GenerateRandomXMLText` verify uniqueness against the real table, or that `GenerateRandomCode` is collision-free even within one test run for a short field — none of that is true.
+- Changed code calls `RecordRef.Open(<table>, true[, ...])` with a literal `true` and then, on that same `RecordRef` with no `Insert` into it, uses `IsEmpty`, `Find`, `FindFirst`, `FindLast`, `FindSet`, `Next`, `Get`, or `Count` to decide whether a value already exists in the table (typically a generate-until-unused loop ending `until RecRef.IsEmpty()`) — `recordref-open-temp-parameter-defeats-real-table-checks`. A temporary open used only as a validation sandbox (`Insert` then `Validate`), to parse a view via `SetView`/`GetFilter`, or to read metadata such as `SystemIdNo` is not this anti-pattern; neither is a non-literal `Temp` argument. A call to `LibraryUtility.GenerateRandomCode` itself is owned by `use-generateguid-for-unique-test-fixture-values`, not this cue.
 - A test asserts against a `TestPage` field's `.Visible()` or `.Enabled()` — `use-testpage-visible-enabled-to-verify-field-ui-state`. When the assertion is against `.Editable()`, or the page is opened with `OpenEdit()` specifically to check editability — `use-testpage-editable-to-verify-field-editability`.
 - A test path raises UI and `[HandlerFunctions(...)]` does not match the invoked handlers, or the test has no meaningful evidence of the UI result (for example, it treats a Boolean set before the action as proof of success) — `ui-handlers-in-tests`. A capture/reset/assert-after-`RunModal` pattern is valid. Enqueue/dequeue and `AssertEmpty` are required only when order, count, text, replies, or a scripted sequence is part of the contract. Only nonoptional handlers have to execute: a listed handler declared `[SendNotificationHandler(true)]` or `[RecallNotificationHandler(true)]` is optional by design, so do not treat it as unmatched when the run never raises the notification.
 - A test's `[GIVEN]`/setup looks up a hardcoded code/number/name assumed to already exist instead of creating it, leaves a mandatory field on a created record empty, uses a value that doesn't satisfy the scenario's own explicit length/format requirement (for example a truncation test whose value never exceeds the field), or a scenario-defining value (amount, quantity, percentage, date, threshold, rounding precision) is generated/randomized instead of an explicit chosen value — `test-data-must-be-random-and-complete`. Generating incidental fixture values (identifiers, names, descriptions) via the standard library codeunits is the compliant shape, not the signal to flag, and neither is a short-but-valid value in an otherwise-unremarkable field.